The apparent increase in popular demand for volumes presenting works of architecture as novelties has been curiously matched by the marked absence of a critical discussion of the objects that would explain and examine their role as cultural statements or as exponents of particular urban, social and political visions. The dearth of architecture criticism, not only in general newspapers or magazines, on television and radio, is a perennial phenomenon.
There are many reasons for the disappearance of the culture of architecture criticism. The progressive acceptance of architecture as image production rather than as an agent of a larger social or political project and the demise of platforms for critical thought, however, are among the most alarming. If architecture is a rich and complex field of cultural production and know ledge that continuously redefines itself vis-à-vis spatial, societal and cultural challenges, then critically thinking and writing on this role of architecture both as a force of change and as a mode of reflection are most essential.
This issue of OASE is aimed at examining the role of the architecture magazine within the current debate on architecture criticism. Resulting from the numerous talks, seminars and symposia organized in the framework of the 25th anniversary of OASE, this issue brings together important critical voices around one central question: ‘What critical role should the architecture journal play in an ever more a-critical landscape?’
OASE 81 / Constructing Criticism
Index OASE 81
001
Hans Teerds, Tom Avermaete, Christoph Grafe, Véronique Patteeuw
Editorial
013
Definitions and Limitations of Criticism
033
Architecture Criticism: Identifying an Object of Study
059
Irénée Scalbert
Faux Amis
065
Françoise Fromonot
Why Start an Architectural Journal in an Age That Is Disgusted with (Most of) Them?
079
(The Lack of) Architecture Criticism in Finland A Plea for Developing Professional Architecture Journalism
093
Maarten Delbeke
The Crowning Glory
101
Pieces of MAS
111
Christophe Van Gerrewey
An Architecture of Distraction
121
The Cocoon of Love
127
Blind Architecture Criticism
133
The House of Angleur
Colophon
- Core editors
- Tom Avermaete, Christoph Grafe, Klaske Havik, Johan Lagae, Véronique Patteeuw, Hans Teerds, Tom Vandeputte
- Editors
- Tom Avermaete, David de Bruijn, Joachim Declerck, Job Floris, Christoph Grafe, Klaske Havik, Anne Holtrop, Johan Lagae, Ruben Molendijk, Véronique Patteeuw, Hans Teerds, Gus Tielens, Tom Vandeputte
- Design
- Karel Martens, Stephen Serrato, Werkplaats Typografie